Friday, May 4, 2012

Auditing the Transmission of Quran

Allah sent Jibreel (Gabriel) to deliver the Quran to Mohammed. Mohammed recites it to his companions, who would memorise them. Many companions who memorised died in battle. The following Muslim website tells us how the Quran was transmitted after that.

QUOTE
During the Battle of Yamamah when a large number of the companions of the Prophet who knew the Quran by heart were killed, Umar ibn Al-Khattab expressed his great worry that some verses of the Quran known to some companions might be forgotten due to the death of those companions. So he suggested to Abu Bakr to have the Quran collected and compiled.

Abu Bakr was hesitant in the beginning, because as he said, "This is something not done by the Prophet." However, he was later convinced of the necessity of the matter, because in the lifetime of the Prophet there was no need for such an action, since the source and conveyor of the revelation was living amongst them.

The Caliph found that Zaid ibn Thabit was the man for the job. Thus he addressed Zaid: "You are a young man who is wise and trustworthy. And you used to write the revelation for the Prophet, collect the Quran and compile it."

Zaid reports, "I swear to God that had they asked me to move a mountain, it would have been easier than that task assigned to me."

Upon the compilation of the whole Book, it was kept with the Caliph Abu Bakr, then his successor Umar, who entrusted it upon his death to his daughter Hafsah, a wife of Prophet Muhammad, who was also known for her knowledge of the Quran besides being one of the few literate people in the community.

In a little while we will look at a few details of the great event of compiling the Book of Islam. But before we start, let me remind our reader that the Quran was memorized by many Companions of the Prophet of Islam during his life time.

It was also written at his orders by his scribes, of whom Zaid ibn Thabit is best known. However, many of those Companions were exposed to death, because of the wars between the armies of Islam and those of the apostates (known in Islamic history as "the Wars of Apostasy").

This was the main reason why Umar ibn Al-Khattab suggested the compilation of the text. The task assigned to Zaid ibn Thabit was to collect the portions scattered with different people, verify the texts and put them in the order assigned to the verses and chapters by the Prophet Muhammad himself before his death.

Though Zaid (the head of the committee) himself knew the whole Quran by heart, along with many others, he followed a very meticulous procedure in its compilation. Following is a brief description:

1. Everyone who knew a portion of the Quran came and reported it to be written by the committee. However, the report was not accepted unless it was heard by the reporting Companion directly from the mouth of the Prophet himself, and the text was checked with the Prophet in his last year of life.
2. The verses and chapters of the text were written in the order assigned to them by the Prophet.
3. In order to ensure authenticity, no text was accepted unless the person who reported it to the Committee brought two witnesses who saw him hear the verses directly from the blessed Prophet's mouth.

Through the above meticulous procedure the committee, which was headed by Zaid ibn Thabit aided by Umar ibn Al-­Khattab, collected the whole text of the Quran, which was then preserved and kept by the Caliph Abu Bakr.

Then, upon his death, by the second Caliph Umar ibn Al-Khattab who entrusted it, upon his death, to his daughter Hafsah, as we mentioned earlier.

It was the Caliph Uthman ibn Affan who had the honor of supervising the distribution of the "standard" version of the Quran during his reign. Again, the task was assigned to our hero Zaid ibn Thabit, aided by a number of reputable Companions of the Prophet.

We learn from history that the Prophet allowed his followers to recite the Holy Quran according to their own dialects. But when the Islamic state expanded, the companions spread all over the newly conquered areas. Each taught the Quran the way he pronounced it.

This caused some confusion, especially to many new converts who could not understand such differences in pronunciation, however slight they were. People almost started fighting over the corrections of each other's way of reciting certain verses.

To avert the chaos and confusion, the great Caliph Uthman ibn Affan consulted the Companions, and made the historical decision of a "standard version" to be followed by everybody. He sent for the text compiled earlier and kept with Hafsah, the widow of the Prophet and daughter of the second Caliph, and he ordered a committee, that included our hero Zaid ibn Thabit, to make copies of that text and have them sent to the major centers of the State.

Then the Caliph Uthman ordered that all other copies be destroyed; thus ensuring the unification of the manner of reciting the Quran, to protect the text from being tampered with, and to protect the Muslim community from fighting over different ways of reciting it.

To this day, whenever we open a copy of the Quran, we may find the expression "according to the 'Uthmani script" in reference to those standard copies made at the order of the Caliph Uthman ibn Affan and executed by Zaid ibn Thabit, with the aid of a few illustrious Companions of the Prophet Muhammad.
UNQUOTE

If you are an auditor, do you have any comment on the way Allah transmit the Quran verbally, without witness, from Gabriel to Mohmammed, then from Mohammed to his companions?

What is your comment on the way Zaid ibn Thabit compile the Quran? Does his method ensure that the whole Quran is collected, or only those that were memorised by the living and available?

No comments: